Star Trek: Discovery 1.12: Vaulting Ambition
Jordon Nardino
Hanelle M. Culpepper
It seems more and more apparent that the second
half of the season is going to be all about revelations in the Mirror Universe
and the fight to survive long enough to make it back to the Prime Universe,
which is frankly quite the adventure.
While there are still some big questions as to how this story might play
out beyond this first season, it definitely feels as though a coherent season
arc is coming to fruition.
The best part about this episode is how it
utilizes Empress Georgiou. I love how
Michelle Yeoh had this opportunity to come back into the story, and it serves
to underscore the differences not only between the Terran Empire and the
Federation, but the different way that Michael’s life unfolded. Since Michael’s personality and that of her
(presumably dead) doppelganger are disturbingly similar, a point driven home in
previous episodes, these conversations play out with a surprising amount of
nuance.
This also turns out to be a plot point, since
all those hints that Lorca is an oddity in the Prime Universe finally come to
something substantial. While the detail
that the light from the Prime Universe causes sensitivity to those from the
Mirror Universe is a new addition that adds fuel to the fire that this is a
separate Mirror Universe entirely, it explains why Lorca was so dramatically
more martial, unorthodox, and psychotic in earlier episodes.
This twist is particularly interesting because,
unlike the clunky reveal with Tyler/Voq, this begs the viewer to go back to
earlier episodes and really see how well it was constructed. My recollection is that it adds up, but there
will also be a bit of work in the next episode to follow through on what
Empress Georgiou was speculating. The
biggest question is how much of Lorca’s apparent plan was dependent on
convenient plotting.
There is definitely a direction that is forming
with the Stamets subplot within the spore network, which is good to see. Not only is it hinting at the method by which
Discovery will go back to the Prime
Universe, but also a way for the spore drive itself to be rendered ultimately
useless. And that’s necessary to cut off
the implication that the technology should have been available on an ongoing
basis in the Prime Universe (or any other, for that matter). So that potential definitely makes me breathe
a little easier, along with the implication that Lorca only pushed so hard for
its use to facilitate his own endgame.
But the death of Dr. Culber continues to be an
open wound, and in some respects, this episode rubs a lot of salt in that
wound. We get a proper goodbye between Stamets
and Culber, at least, but if this is what the producers meant when they said
that his death scene wasn’t the end for the character, it’s going to feel like
a real cheat. I suppose that one could
take some solace in the fact that Stamets/Culber was the only relationship with
depth enough to have the impact that it did when Tyler/Voq went rogue, but it
doesn’t change the context of what happened.
There are three episodes left this season, and
still quite a lot of ground to cover to bring a lot of the open threads of the
narrative to a conclusion. I suspect the
general tone of the opinions for Discovery
will depend greatly upon how these final few episodes deliver.
- The Lorca reveal was well played
- Michael’s central role in the narrative is even more cemented
- Was this really how Culber was supposed to “come back”?