Star Trek: Discovery 1.11: The Wolf Inside
Lisa Randolph
TJ Scott
Discovery’s ordeal in the Mirror
Universe continues, but this episode is largely focused on the relationship
between Michael and Tyler. And as one
would expect, it does not end well, though it serves to unravel more of the
mystery around Tyler and what happened to him during his time with the
Klingons.
Tyler reveals that he is actually Voq. In essence, Voq went deep undercover in the
form of Tyler to infiltrate the ship that posed the most danger to the Klingons
in the war, which tracks somewhat with the interest in the spore drive that the
Klingons showed earlier in the season.
It’s a plot point that only really works because of Lorca’s
unconventional attitude about field promotions and assignments; as much as
events conspired to put Lorca in a position to trust Tyler, there was really no
way Voq or anyone else could have known what would happen once Tyler was on
board.
It also feels like the kind of plot twist that
would work better if the audience knew the characters longer or better, which
gets back to some of the early observations about how the writers push too fast
or too hard on certain plot and character beats. Michael and Tyler’s relationship is really
just beginning, so while the sense of betrayal is there, it’s not as potent as
if the audience had lots of time to know Tyler in his role on the ship under
normal circumstances.
But that twist at least works on some level,
and supports much of the fast-paced plotting that centers on Michael and her
attempts to negotiate her way through the Mirror Universe. There are complications galore, and most of
them play on the question of how much or how little the characters differ
between the universes. And the
revelation that Georgiou is the Empress of the Terran Empire is a perfect
touch; not only does it bring back a character that didn’t have enough screen
time, but it makes the entire episode an exercise in breaking Michael down.
It’s that potential that makes it so easy to
forgive the leaps that got us to this point.
Michael actually feels like the central character finally, and all of
these experiences are designed to maximize the stress that Michael must
endure. And that, in turn, serves to
reveal the kind of person Michael ultimately is. At least, that’s the theory; the question is
how well the writers will deliver on the execution.
Meanwhile, Tilly is doing her best to restore
Stamets, but it doesn’t seem to be working.
Instead, his further immersion in the “spore network” brings him into connection
with his Mirror Universe doppelganger, which will likely serve as the means to
his restoration and thus a way back home.
With the purpose of the Mirror Universe sojourn for Michael’s character
study now front and center, it gives this portion of the story arc a
discernable lifespan.
It also makes me wonder if the speed of the
narrative beats is a relic of the original plan to have this setting and crew
be a single-season arc. It would all
make a lot more sense, or at least feel less unnecessary, if there was an
expectation that all the plot and character threads would not to be resolved in
the next few episodes. It actually
leaves me mildly concerned how they intend to push this past its original
intended run.
- The Georgiou reveal is very effective
- The focus on Michael makes sense of her role as a central character finally
- The reveal for Tyler feels a bit rushed