Arrow 4.23: Schism
Greg Berlanti, Wendy Mericle, and Marc Guggenheim
John Behring
Arrow seemed to
never really recover from Laurel's death. Not to again make such a big deal
about her departure because everything about that death has been rehashed over
and over, but in the wake of the season finale's airing, the excitement on the
show isn't there. Damien Darhk's Genesis plan became more and more convoluted
as the end of the season approached, and with the destruction of Tevet Noah in
"Lost in the Flood," his magical abilities and menace seemed to
lessen by the time that "Schism" approached. That said, Neal
McDonough does bring his all to the role, which does make for a compelling
villain for Team Arrow to combat all the way to the end.
The thing is,
the introduction of the use of nuclear weapons doesn't prove to be as effective
as the show thought it was. The mechanics of Darhk launching a missile that
destroys Havenrock in order to gain more fuel to power his magical abilities
wasn't explained all that well from "Monument Point" on, as well as
the fact that a nuclear missile detonated on American soil seemed to be
dismissed. The closest explanation I could derive is perhaps the distance
between Havenrock and Star City is close enough for Darhk to consume all that
power from all the people who were killed in the blast. This show has never
been that precise when it comes to explaining things happening from outside of
its own little world.
Darhk's
motivations are simple enough, though. Team Arrow allowed for Anarky to kill
his wife so he plans to burn the world to the ground as revenge. And Oliver
seems resolute in the fact that he just can't defeat Darhk on his own.
Throughout the finale (as well as pretty much the whole season), the
indications are there to set up the separation of the remaining members of Team
Arrow. Diggle hasn't really been the same stand-up hero-type guy since he had
to kill his little brother in cold blood. Yes, circumstances dictated that John
had no choice but to kill Andy, but that fact still doesn't diminish the
reality that he committed murder. Thea spent most of this episode realizing
that she was becoming more and more like Malcolm by threatening to murder an
innocent child. Darhk's daughter, by the way, appears to not be too damaged by
the fact that her mother has been killed and that her father is a supervillain
with magical abilities, or that there is a masked superhero who is trying to
kill her father.
Anyway, the
prospect of nuclear annihilation does force everyone in Star City to consider
turning against Darhk and his Ghost soldiers. They all seem fine with no longer
having shelter against nuclear fallout, which makes the reactions of the
citizens of Star City seem rather muted by comparison. Oliver tries his hardest
to rally all of them, to get them to stand up and fight against Darhk, though
the words in his speech do feel ineffective in light of impending doom and
destruction. It nearly gets to that point, as Curtis and Felicity spend a few
minutes in the episode diverting one of the 15,000 launched nuclear missiles
from hitting Star City. That actually proved to be one of the more suspenseful
and tense sequences, as I was worried that the writers would go ahead and nuke
Star City, or at least detonate the missile on the edge of the city, but all of
Felicity and Curtis' technobabble saves Star City from being burned to the
ground at the last minute. The technical prowess demonstrated by Felicity,
Curtis, and Felicity's father has constantly been the saving grace for many
situations on the show. Somehow, that doesn't really get old, even as it feels
somewhat predictable each time it's used.
Oliver's
rallying cry is at least effective enough to get the people of Star City to
stand up and try to save their home from Darhk's plans. The final fight
sequence has the requisite excitement that is usually brought by the show's
standards. And yet, when Oliver finally defeats Darhk, stabbing him in the gut
with an arrow in the same manner that Darhk killed Laurel, everything stops. He
brings up the different choices he had to face when battling Slade Wilson or
when he tried to stop the Undertaking, and, like John with Andy, Darhk just
left him with no other choice but to end the threat. Darhk is too dangerous to
be locked up like Slade Wilson was.
So the season's central conflict has been resolved. A bit too cleanly, but at least it doesn't dissolve into a mess like sister show The Flash did with its finale. There's a strange beauty in the denouement for the season. Each member of Team Arrow determines that they need some time away. The actors try to sell a semblance of permanence to the whole thing, and it's effective in the beginning, until one realizes that they will all be pulled back to Star City one way or another. The Oliver in the flashbacks has his mission in Russia to look forward to. All that's left is Felicity and Oliver in the present, with Oliver now the mayor of Star City, which feels like the inverse of what ended last season. Everyone has changed in some big ways from who they were at the beginning of this season. They would understandably need some time to process everything before going back to being heroes again. Maybe true change can be a good thing for the show.
- Damien Darhk remains a compelling villain to the end, at least in terms of portrayal
- Oliver’s rallying cry was a highlight of the episode
- The nuclear threat never came together like the writers intended